Eminem - The Eminem Show
Reviewed by erun
It took me a LONG time to review this album. Why? Because this album, by Mr. Controversy, Marshall Mathers aka Slim Shady aka Eminem, is so terribly good. I tried to find knots, I tried to find little pockets of bad bits, I tried to be overly critical. I read every available article about Eminem, trying to grab a foothold on something that would keep this review from being a kiss-arse. It was so difficult, because this album was totally brilliant and addictive, easy to enjoy, easy to put in the CD player. It's cynical, it's smart, it's cheeky, it's un-PC, it's gleefully entertaining. Eminem, you made a good album. Okay, so there's no denying the obvious talent that Eminem has under tap, and he knows how actually irremarkable he is in terms of controversy ("Like I'm the first rapper to smack a bitch or say faggot?"-"White America") as well as how precious his carrer is ("My insecurities could eat me alive"- "Hallie's Song" and "I know I'll probably never get the props I deserve" - "Sing for the Moment") but he's irrepressably funny and so clever. Have you figured out that I was impressed yet? Are you surprised? I was. I usually get irritated by overt misogyny, childish name-calling, and anything having to do with homophobia. But it seems a part of Eminem's character, a part of his anger-management: He might not mean it so much as he only means it when he's angry. Not since Kurt Cobain has there been so much vitriol to be purged. The only difference (c'mon, hear me out) is that Emimen has a sense of humor about the world, while Kurt was more apt to rage against it. In terms of beats and breaks, well, that's the docking of the ".5" on this album's rating, because there's obligatory samples, obligatory rollicking pieces that, while they make Dr. Dre raise hell again, Eminem seems just to be comfortable in them, as oppossed to really feeling them. But then there's the silly, OutKast influenced track "Square Dance", which is easily the best rap track I've heard since "B.O.B.", as it boasts a goofy and southern-fried beat and the BEST flow on the whole album: "psychotic, hypnotic product I got it the antibiotic, ain't nobody hotter and so on/and yada yada, god I talk a lotta hem de lay la la la, oochie walla um da dah da dah da but you gotta gotta/ keep movin'..." You gotta hear it- This is part of the process of purging Bubba Sparxx from our collective unconcious. "Business" has Dr. Dre getting mad again as a Batman to Eminem's Robin ("Holy whack unlyrical lyrics, AnDre!"), and his "Hell Yeah!" makes the track, while "Cleaning Out My Closet" is adressing Eminem's multiple personality issues, as the verses are angry and bitter, yet the chorus is almost sad and apologetic (to his mother) and, notably, the theme to Eminem's new movie "8 Mile." More? Then there's some skits ("The Kiss", "Paul Rosenburg", "Steve Berman", and "Curtains Close") which fill time between tracks. "Soldier" assures us that Eminem is with us for the long haul, despite his temper, and "Say Goodbye to Hollywood" is a token pain of fame song. "Drips" is an ode to STD's and is fairly boring, actually, as Obie isn't very entertaining, and "Without Me" you've probably heard enough to be tired of and need not my commentary. "Sing for the Moment" samples Areosmith's "Sing With Me" and retains it's dissention and hoplessness, only now tainted with Eminem's tales of despair- That's another docking of points, as it's such an obvious sample. "Superman" gives Eminem a chance to get mad at girls again in a very (admit it) funny way, while "Hallie's Song" which was originally to be backed by George Harrison's "While My Guitar Gently Weeps" (you can tell) is honestly hearfelt, genuine, and, yeah, sang... er, nice try. "My Dad's Gone Crazy" is a fun song with Eminem's daughter guesting on the chorus and a Beverly Hillbillies beat, while "'Til I Collapse" (Queen sample & token Nate Dogg guest vocal) and "When the Music Stops" are more socio-political motivated songs. Dre and Eminem collaborate on a marginal "Say What You Say". Honestly, and I wouldn't lie to you, the album's great. It's brilliant, it's wonderful. It's not the best album ever, but it definitley proves that Eminem is not the white-rapper novelty of Vanilla Ice or the weary has-been of Everlast: This is not rap-rock, this guy is as honest as he's going to be, he utilizes free speech enough to make it seem ludicrious, yet he's undeniably good, and he delivers. Get the album, and I bet you won't be dissapointed. [www.eminem.com]