The Beautiful Mistake - Light A Match, For I Deserve to Burn
Reviewed by erun
I. Am. Tired. Of. White. Boy. Angst. I am tired of white boy melody-guitar coupled with nasally, tear-stained lyrics. I am tired of the soft/loud jump that comes with anything semi-popular now. I am tired of cardigans and screams punctuating shimmery guitar. But I will tell you that "The Beautiful Mistake" are talented young men. They are "impassioned / misunderstood". They know how to craft pretty songs that have some real musicianship ("Stavesail" has the same opening riff of Incubus' "How Do You Do It" but hey, it changes later...), and they can make you feel starry-eyed and pitifully lost in a world of frustation ("Circular Parade"). "Anonymous vs. California", though, is the best song on the album... In terms of representing why this album gets such a poor rating from me. The lyrics are fortuitously good "Confusion plays a solemn tune/ The Poet steals a thought" but they're either sung with a hardly urgent voice or screamed horrifically off-key. I laughed. Maybe if you like to wallow in the past, you might like it- And it's totally cool if you do, that's why I listen to Nirvana. But see, Nirvana's got something these boys just don't, and it's jaded, thoughtfully-articulated-but-still-angry-pain, and The Beautiful Mistake's pain is too raw, too Tonic, too starry-eyed for my liking. One thing I will give them: Terrific album design. Best I've seen in awhile... But album design not a good album make. [www.themilitiagroup.com]