Phantom Planet - Phantom Planet
Reviewed by holmes
What blows my mind about Phantom Planet's 2004 self-titled release, the follow-up to the really quirky and cool The Guest, is that they somehow got Dave Fridmann, master of the "wall of sound" technique, to make them sound a lot like The Strokes. That's not a slag on the band by any means; in fact, this CD is rather good. It's just amazing that the man responsible for the Flaming Lips' and Longwave's sweeping sounds took on a power-pop band and adapted a real garage-y sound. Phantom Planet has stripped off their former influences, such as Fountains Of Wayne and Superdrag and Weezer, in favor of a French Kicks/Strokes sound. Maybe they were as sick as we were of hearing "California" being played FOX every other minute. Whatever it was, they got dirty for this release, and it's pretty cool that they did. I do miss Alex Greenwald's cool voice singing like on The Guest, but his new Casablancas-crooning style isn't bad at all. The first half of the album is really really raw, but by the end of the CD you'll hear the pop band that you've heard before, which I think is the best part of the CD. This CD, though, may be very frustrating to some people. On one hand, O.C. viewers may pick this up and be appalled by it. The garage kids may pick this up and feel Phantom Planet has no cred. Regardless, this is a really unapologetic pop CD, some of it really raw and some of it showing the band's true colors. It's definitely worth the time to check out if you're even remotely interested in the band or the sound. Or the O.C. [www.phantomplanet.com]